| What We Do |
Contact Us |
|
The China Business Scene
Click on the links below or scroll down to view a particular topic or news brief. Huge Increase in Patent Applications Partners Sought for Silicon Valley Computer Festival Problem of Suspended Particle Pollution Tops Agenda Pollutant Beijing Buses to be Banned from Downtown Beijing Striving to Lessen Burden for Foreign Investors Greater Access to China for Foreign Publications China's Electronics Industry Enjoys $70 Billion Investment Hydrogen Fuel Cell Bus to Appear on Beijing / Shanghai Streets Sales of Chinese-made Vehicles Continue to Rocket SAFE Eases Control on Purchase of Foreign Exchange Tips in Structuring a Joint Venture How is Your Chinese Partner? Checks that Pay
Huge
Increase in Patent Applications--reported by Business Beijing,
April 2003 (Back
to Top) Partners
Sought for Silicon Valley's Computer Festival--reported by Business
Beijing, April 2003 (Back
to Top) Problem
of Suspended Particle Pollution Tops Agenda--reported by Business
Beijing, April 2003 (Back
to Top) Pollutant
Beijing Buses to be Banned from Downtown--reported by Business
Beijing, April 2003 (Back
to Top) Beijing
Striving to Lessen Burden for Foreign Investors--reported by Business
Beijing, April 2003 (Back
to Top) Greater
Access to China for Foreign Publications--reported by Business
Beijing, April 2003 (Back
to Top) China's
Electronics Industry Enjoys $70 billion Investment--reported by Business
Beijing, April 2003 (Back
to Top) Hydrogen
Fuel Cell Bus to Appear on Beijing / Shanghai Streets--reported by
Business Beijing, April 2003 (Back
to Top) Sales
of Chinese-made Vehicles Continue to Rocket--reported by Business
Beijing, April 2003 (Back
to Top) SAFE
Eases Control on Purchase of Foreign Exchange--reported by Business
Beijing, April 2003 (Back
to Top) Tips
in Structuring a Joint Venture--reported
by Chris Devonshire-Ellis, China Briefing, March 2003
(Back
to Top) Management: Many companies let the Chinese parnter run all operations, which is a crucial mistake. A new business needs all the support it can get, and it is important to invest in a foreign manager to keep an eye on things, especially during the early stages. Correct systems, accounting, and quality control should all be put in place to ensure your standards are all operational in your JV. The ideal solution is an expatriate manager, if not long term then at least for the initial stages. The Chairman position--the legally responsible person--is probably best left to the Chinese side. It is wise, however, to make the general manager one of your personnel as he or she will be responsible for operations. Leaving both to your Chinese partner effectively gives them control of the business. Capital Investment: When negotiating the amount make sure that the Chinese partner's investment really is worth that amount of money. Asset and stock valuations to verify these are a pre-requisite. This means having property valuations placed on machinery (the Chinese tend to quote the original purchase price with no depreciation); buildings are frequently valued at the price it would cost today to build and don't actually reflect the fact that it may well be a 15 year old shack that cost US$ 10,000 to put up in 1988. Also, check the Land Use Rights certificate--if your partner can show these are granted rights then he or she owns the land. If they are just allocated then the right to use the land should just be the rental value. Royalties: This can be incorporated as part of your investment. Patents and trademarks should be properly registered in China as being your property if you want to retain control over these. Technology Transfer can be paid in the form of royalties from the JV, but ensure contracts are in place and that you understand the legal and tax implications; don't just assume it will be 'taken care of.' Withholding tax applies on royalty contracts at a lower rate than profits tax so taking care of these agreements saves money. Profits Repatriation: It is important to make sure this is properly addressed as your Chinese partner is not so concerned about this and won't be familiar with the procedures in any event. It's your problem, not your partner's and he or she will not have any experience in this matter. You can draw money out of the business in pre-tax expenses (see the December 2002 and March 2002 issues of China Briefing at www.china-briefing.com in the Archives section for further information or contact Dezan Shira & Associates for advise). Also ensure that you know the mechanisms and have enhanced your ability to repatriate funds as much as possible. Mergers / Acquisitions: Not covered in basic drafts, be sure to build into the contract and articles proper mechanisms outlining exactly the procedures and protocol for changing ownership, buying and selling shares in the company, share valuations and so on. Amendments to articles require government approval. Highlighting your intentions later on may result in problems with getting amendments considered to be in your favour approved, so it is better to build these mechanisms from the beginning. Exit Strategy: Clearly define what are considered to be unacceptible levels of business (losses in consecutive years, production below targeted levels, etc.) and have these agreed upon and set in the contract and articles. Often they are not and this can lead to problems getting you out of a JV if the government does not agree with your assesment of what is and is not a viable business. Make sure economic performance is properly identified as a clear reason to effect closure if things go badly. How
is Your Chinese Partner? Checks that Pay--reported
by Chris Devonshire-Ellis, China Briefing, March 2003
(Back
to Top) Chinese business licence: You should ask for a copy of this. It will list (in Chinese) the details of the legally responsible person,registered address, amount of registered capital (which is also the limited liability) and the period of the licence. This basic information should be compared with what you know and if there are any discrepancies find out the reasons why. It is relatively common for the person you are dealing with not to be the person legally responsible for the business. Licence periods may not be consistent with liabilities they are entering into--such as the case of the ten year projected joint venture with a Chinese partner whose licence was due to expire in three months time! Capital Verification Report: This is issued by an independent CPA firm confirming the fact that the registered capital as identified on the business licence was in fact paid up. Often it is not. Not only does this indicate that your partner has not actually capitalised his business, it also means that he has not complied with the limited liability (the amount of registered capital is also the extent of limited liability) requirements but will also be in breach of his own articles of association, which could lead to termination of his company. This could cause serious problems in the event of a failure or other legal issues. Land Use Rights: What is the status of the land on which your Chinese partner has his premises? Allocated rights are issued to a venture for a period of years (check the timeframe) but only give the right to use the land. This is okay, but means that any development (i.e. buildings) that is erected on the land will ultimately benefit the landowner and not your company. In addition, if the land agreement is between your Chinese partner and the landlord directly, if your Chinese partner defaults on the rental agreement you can be thrown off the premises. Investigate this and make sure that you have agreements in place in terms of letters of intent from the landlord directly to circumnavigate this eventuality. It is also important to ascertain whether or not your intended Chinese JV partner actually owns the land he claims to be 'injecting' as part of his capital in any potential JV. Contrary to allocated rights, granted rights are issued for a period of years but give title to the land during this timeframe. If you are in China for the long haul and plan to have significant investment on the site you may want to consider having granted rights. It costs more for granted rights, but if such rights are in your JV name you may use these to raise loans in China (giving the granted rights as security) and even profit from any sale of the rights later on. In the long term strategy this secures your China future. If your Chinese partner injects land as part of JV equity, he must provide granted land use rights, otherwise the gesture is meaningless. Copies of Filed Accounts: These can be difficult to extract from your partner because often they have been operating two sets of books--one set internally, which shows true position, and one officially, which provides the 'official' position! Of course this is illegal but in China it is extremely common. Official accounts may seriously understate profitability and inflate overheads and business costs to reduce tax liabilities. For this reason your Chinese partner may not want to expose these to you, especially if you have already seen his 'real' version of the events. If in doubt, ask a CPA firm to conduct an 'asset appraisal report,' which will provide a private confirmation of assets and the close-to-true picture. This probably should not be conducted by the partner's usual accountants. Alternatively, ask a firm to evaluate any books as presented to you and ask for a professional opinion. At the very least you will have an idea of where discrepancies lie and can then talk about these matters in private, frank talks with your partner without making him feel as if he is in any danger of being under official scrutiny. Summary: Don't be surprised if these basic checks reveal irregularities--they probably will. At least then you are in the position to understand whether or not this is a critical problem or is just a 'Chinese' issue. These checks are, however, the first basic steps and represent the absolute minimum checks you should be undertaking. Contact a professional firm for more assistance. |
| |